Established in 1939 by Paolo Sartori, Sartori Cheese Company is a fourth generation family owned business based in Plymouth, Wisconsin.
Well known for hard and Italian-style cheeses, the company sources milk from local, family owned farms within a close radius to the production facility. The herd size at each farm averages 75 cows and many of the farms have worked with Sartori for multiple generations. The company also operates an incentive program that encourages each farm to produce the best quality milk possible.
For production of Sartori’s cheeses, the milk is heated, cultures and rennet are added and, once the milk has coagulated, the curd is cut, releasing the whey, which is drained off.
The remaining curd is hand-salted and transferred into hoops, then pressed for several hours. Newly formed wheels of cheese are placed in a warm “overnight” room to encourage the expulsion of more whey.
Wheels are then trimmed by hand and placed in a brine bath, which encourages the formation of a rind. After the brine bath, the cheese is moved to a curing room for further maturation.
Each variety of cheese is matured for a different length of time. Every batch is tasted at regular intervals during this period and, when they are deemed ready, released for sale.
For Extra-Aged Fontina, Sartori’s cheesemakers allow a peppery young Fontina to age for 6-10 months, which is three times longer than usual.
The aging process enhances and richens the flavors of the cheese. Taste is gentle and unassuming, neither sharp nor salty. A mild lactic scent acts as a prologue to the smooth milky and buttery flavor, rounded out at the finish with a pleasant tang.
Pair it with a Chianti, an Asti Spumanti, a Sauvignon Blanc, a Merlot or a Sherry. For beer pairings, try an IPA, an American pale ale, or a lager.