We have a long history of serving milk punch at Craigie On Main. The drink requires more initial work, but the delicious result is a crystal-clear, milky-sweet yet light-bodied liqueur. This rendition features coffee and chocolate dimensions, as well as a touch of fruit, for a perfect post-dinner sip.
*Averna adds beautiful depth to the final beverage. If you can’t find it, substitute more Kahlúa to make up the difference. Fernet-Branca is more widely available and may be substituted for Averna, but it will give the punch a slightly bitter, menthol-laced taste. Luxardo Amaro Abano is another possible substitute, but it’s also hard to locate.