The Best Mail-Order Cheese Boards for Holiday Gifting | culture: the word on cheese
☰ menu   

The Best Mail-Order Cheese Boards for Holiday Gifting


We put four mail-order cheese boards to the test to see whether they could deliver on the promise of effortless entertaining.

The holidays are prime for cheese buying, and these days, there are plenty of ways to get your hands on the good stuff. Maybe you’re lucky enough to live near an independent cheesemonger or a Costco that stocks Rush Creek Reserve. But if neither is an option, there’s no shortage of online cheese retailers willing to ship something delicious straight to your door.

If you’re looking to buy a cheese board for your holiday party, your local cheese shop or one of the many pandemic-era, Instagram-born charcuterie board companies can put one together for you. But what if you want to send a fully-assembled cheese board to someone who lives across the country—one that’s arranged and ready to serve, without the recipient having to do much more than unwrap it?

With the gifting and entertaining season upon us, I went looking for companies offering just that. As it turns out, there aren’t many. I found two companies shipping ready-to-serve, fully composed cheese boards: Murray’s Cheese, the longtime New York City-based cheesemonger, and Boarderie, the Florida-based company that appeared on Shark Tank. Both promise a beautiful, ready-to-serve spread delivered right to your door.

Since the options were surprisingly limited, I expanded my search to include build-your-own kits from Curdbox and Rogue Creamery. While plenty of cheesemakers and retailers offer gift boxes with cheese and accompaniments, I was specifically looking for products marketed as complete cheese boards with step-by-step illustrated instructions. Not quite the same as having everything done for you, but a much more affordable and simple option to produce and ship.

All of these boards are curated by the companies, meaning you can’t customize the cheeses you receive. I ordered all four to see how they stacked up. Would they arrive cold and intact? How much work would it take to get them on the table? How much food would I actually get? And, most importantly, how would the cheese taste?

Murray’s Small Fireside Bites Cheese & Charcuterie Board

  • Price: $165 (free shipping)
  • Total food weight: 4.04 lb
  • Total cheese weight: 1.96 lb
  • Serves: 5–8 (manufacturer estimate)
  • What’s included: Four cheeses (Sartori Pumpkin Spice BellaVitano, 5 Spoke Creamery Harvest Moon, Murray’s Smoked Cheddar Brick, and Point Reyes Mini Quinta), one salami, two types of crackers, two jams, cornichons, Marcona almonds, dried apricots, dried pears, dried cranberries, service utensils, reusable serving board.

Murray’s arrived cold and on time, with four ice packs and fairly basic packaging. It wasn’t a huge wow moment to unbox, but everything arrived in excellent condition. Once I got the plastic off, though, I was impressed. The board was overflowing, with a beautiful mix of colors and textures. The cheese was clearly cut by a professional, with sharp edges and interesting shapes. I also appreciated the little cheese signs, which are a nice touch when serving a group. 

There was some assembly required beyond opening plastic bags. I had to slice the salami, find bowls for the crackers, and cut the top off the Point Reyes Mini Quinta. None of this was difficult, and it was obvious where everything belonged, but some instructions for the Quinta might have been useful for the uninitiated.

The four cheeses were all made with cow’s milk, but offered a good range of textures, from hard and crumbly to semi-firm and soft. The portions were thoughtfully cut and mostly bite-sized (though I would have cut the pumpkin BellaVitano a little smaller). With more than 85 individual pieces of cheese, this felt like a board up to 10 people could share.

As for the cheese itself, I absolutely loved the Mini Quinta. Any cheesemonger can tell you that a bark-wrapped cheese is only as good as the day you serve it. Too early and it’s cakey; too late and it’s ammoniated. This one arrived at peak ripeness: sweet, milky, and perfectly drippy—a testament to the cheesemongers who selected it. The smoked cheddar and pumpkin BellaVitano were good, but I would have happily traded some of those portions for a fifth cheese.

Murray’s delivered more cheese than any other board I tested, with professional selection and preparation, and a beautiful presentation. The cheeses and accompaniments were paired nicely, and it stored well over several days. It delivered on value for the price and is one I would happily serve at my own party.

Packaging & Delivery: 4/5
Presentation: 5/5
Curation: 5/5
Cheese Quality: 5/5
Likelihood I would send this as a gift? 5/5

Boarderie Classic Medium Cheese & Charcuterie Board

  • Price: $169 (free shipping)
  • Total food weight: 2.70 lb
  • Cheese weight: 1.11 lb
  • Serves: 4–6 (manufacturer estimate)
  • What’s Included: Seven cheeses (Creamy Aged Gouda, Double-Cream Gouda, Peppadew Pepper White Cheddar, Apple Smoked Cheddar, Merlot Pecorino, Cranberry Wensleydale, and Fig & Rose Goat Cheese), two charcuteries, crackers, three varieties of spiced nuts, three dried fruits, olives, sun-dried tomatoes, pepperoncini, and chocolate-covered espresso beans.

Boarderie gets high marks for packaging. The board arrived cold and on time in a large, custom-printed box that made opening it feel like an “unboxing.” It even arrived upside down, which had me a little worried, but everything was intact. 

The board itself was colorful, with plenty of variety, but upon closer inspection, the board didn’t quite live up to its packaging. It lacked height—as in it was flat—and I was immediately struck by how big the cheese portions were. There were just 21 pieces, many large enough to cut into thirds. Some had frayed edges and indentations from vacuum packaging, which made the board look a little sloppy.

There was very little assembly required, and I liked that the salami was pre-sliced. However, there was a lot of plastic to unwrap, including little trays filled with individually bagged nuts. With no obvious place for them on the board, I scattered them around like in the picture. That turned out to be a mistake. After a night wrapped in the fridge, the candied nuts had turned sticky and coated most of the cheeses in sugary syrup.

I appreciated the inclusion of goat cheese and two types of salami, but despite having seven cheese varieties, they were all fairly similar. I enjoyed the peppadew cheddar, both goudas, and the merlot pecorino, but nothing stood out, and the cranberry Wensleydale had a gritty texture I couldn’t get past. The accompaniments leaned on the sweet side, and the chocolate-covered espresso beans felt out of place.

Ultimately, Boarderie delivered the most variety of any board I tried, but it didn’t feel particularly curated or balanced. There was a lot going on, without much sense of how the cheeses and accompaniments were meant to work together. The gift-worthy packaging and minimal prep were definite selling points, but for the price, I wanted the cheese itself to make a stronger impression.

Packaging & Delivery: 5/5
Presentation: 4/5
Curation: 2/5
Cheese Quality: 3/5
Likelihood I would send this as a gift? 2/5

Curdbox: That Cheese Plate, At Home

  • Price: $115 (plus $20 shipping)
  • Total food weight: 2.35 lb
  • Cheese weight: 1.13 lb
  • Serves: 6–8 (manufacturer estimate)
  • What’s Included: Three cheeses (Marieke Farmstead Aged Gouda, Jasper Hill Farm Vault 5 Cheddar, and Vermont Farmstead Brie), salami, crackers, almonds, olives, dried apricots, jam, fresh rosemary, and illustrated board assembly instructions.

Curdbox teamed up with Marissa Mullen of That Cheese Plate to create this build-your-own board, complete with her signature Cheese by Numbers step-by-step instructions. The box arrived on time and in good condition. The ice packs had thawed on an unusually hot November day, but the cheese was still cool.

I was excited to see a few of my favorite cheeses in the box! Cheddar, brie, and gouda–could there be a more crowd-pleasing combination of cheeses? I especially appreciated that the products came in their original packaging, so someone could learn a little about the makers behind them. The accompaniments offered plenty of opportunities to mix and match, with pairing suggestions and a special playlist to set the vibe. 

The cheese cutting was simple: halve the brie, slice some of the gouda, and chunk the cheddar into shards, and a pre-sliced salami. This is a novice-friendly board in terms of knife skills and food styling, and I mean that in a good way. This would be accessible for anyone to receive as a gift and recreate in their own kitchen.

What I liked most about this box was the cheese curation, it featured a variety of cheese textures and fun pairing items to explore them with. And, as one of the first and most well-known cheese influencers out there, I can imagine there are plenty of people excited to bring That Cheese Plate to life in their own home.

Packaging & Delivery: 4/5
Ease of Setup: 5/5
Curation: 5/5
Cheese Quality: 5/5
Likelihood I would send this as a gift? 4/5

Rogue Creamery: The Perfect Cheeseboard

  • Price: $115 (plus $13 for 2-day shipping)
  • Total product weight: 3.20 lb
  • Cheese weight: Approximately 1.4 lb
  • Serves: Not confirmed
  • What’s Included: Three cheeses (Oregon Blue, Touvelle Original, and Rogue’s Mary Herbed), one salami, hazelnuts, olives, crackers, jam, and illustrated board assembly instructions.

Rogue Creamery managed to pack an impressive amount of food into a surprisingly small box—once I took it all out, I could not figure out how to Tetris it back together. Everything arrived cold and in good condition, tucked into branded packaging that felt fun and gift-worthy. 

Like Curdbox, Rogue included illustrated, step-by-step instructions for assembling the board. There was a little prep involved, including slicing salami and cutting cheeses into different shapes. A cheese-cutting guide might have helped a novice, but overall, the instructions were easy to follow. The final step suggested adding your own fruit or chocolate, but I stuck with what came in the box for a fair comparison. Even without the extras, the finished board looked full and abundant.

The cheeses were the highlight, as you might expect from Rogue Creamery. The selection offered a nice range of flavors and textures. Although I personally would have been happy with two blues, I recognize that not everyone shares my enthusiasm, and the milder cheeses made the board more approachable. The apricot riesling and vanilla jam was a particularly good pairing with the Oregon Blue.

One of my favorite things about this kit is that you’re buying it directly from the cheesemaker and it features other Oregon-made products (including the state’s famous hazelnuts), so you can really immerse yourself in the region. 

Packaging & Delivery: 5/5
Ease of Setup: 5/5
Curation: 5/5
Cheese Quality: 5/5
Likelihood I would send this as a gift? 4/5

So, Which Board Would I Gift?

After trying all four boards, I think there’s a place for both ready-to-serve and build-your-own options. The ready-to-serve boards take most of the work out of entertaining, while the DIY kits turn building a cheese board into part of the fun (and give you a little more bang for your buck). Both make appealing gifts, but for different people and occasions.

Of the ready-to-serve options, Murray’s was my clear favorite. At nearly identical prices, Boarderie offered a wider variety and an impressive unboxing experience, but Murray’s delivered nearly twice as much cheese, better quality, and a more thoughtfully curated selection. I couldn’t help feeling that with Boarderie, I was paying more for packaging than cheese.

More importantly, the Murray’s board was clearly selected and built by a cheesemonger. The cheeses were professionally cut and arranged, and every cheese was identified by its name and maker. Boarderie offered seven varieties, but little information about the cheeses themselves, let alone their makers. For someone interested in cheese, that’s a missed opportunity.

As for the build-your-own kits, I had a harder time choosing a favorite. Curdbox offered a wider variety of cheese styles from different makers, while Rogue delivered more cheese and the added appeal of buying directly from a cheesemaker. Both were easy to assemble, and I’d happily give either as a gift.

Of course, these aren’t the only companies offering cheese boards or gift boxes. If you’re shopping elsewhere, I’d look beyond the number of cheeses or the presentation in the product photos. Are the cheeses and makers identified? Is there a range of textures and milk types? And when it comes to accompaniments, more is not always better.

I did find myself wishing some of the cheeses were a little weirder. Then again, if I’m looking for stinky-foot cheese, I’ll probably just head down to my local cheese shop (shoutout Talbott & Arding) and pick them out myself. Which brings me to what I think is the real purpose of these products: they’re meant to be gifts. They’re designed to be shared with a group of people whose tastes you might not know, and to feel like a special gesture. And on that front, all of these products have something to offer.

Josie Krogh

Josie Krogh is culture's Digital Strategy Lead. She earned her master's degree in Agricultural and Applied Economics from The University of Georgia. Josie developed a love of food while working at farmstands in the D.C. area as a young adult, and discovered her love of cheese while living and working on a dairy farm on Martha's Vineyard. Josie currently lives in Catskill, NY.

Leave a Reply

4